IDFleet Forum
    > General Conversations
        > Curiosity...
New Topic    New Poll    Add Reply

<< Prev Topic | Next Topic >>
Author
Comment
FDragonetti
Registered User
(2/7/03 11:24 am)
Reply

Curiosity...
I have to write this huge essay of English class. The topic is "Just War and Terrorism" using the Just War Doctrine? Does anyone else know anything about this, or have any opinions about this. I would like to get some ideas on what to write but I am so stuck ) :. Thanks everyone, I appreciate it.

RAdm. Dragonetti
Commanding Officer
USS Patriot, NCC-26782
Director of Defense

Seldon11988
Administrator
(2/7/03 11:33 am)
Reply

Suggestions
That seems like a very interesting topic. What is the suggested length for it?

If the topic is "Just War and Terrorism" here are some things that you may want to consider:

-- Is terrorism ever justifiable? Is it so in this case?

-- Is the war on terrorism just? Why or why not?

-- For either, what, if any, are the limits to a just war of terror or on terror?

-- What role does the international community play in justifying or condemning a war? That is, can a UN vote or lack thereof make a war just or unjust? If so, is a UN vote a necessary condition or a sufficient condition for waging a just war? (That is, does a UN vote alone justify a war or is it only one needed component of doing so?)

-- The above question, if you deal with it at any length, naturally produces questions on national sovereignty and the nature of statehood.

-- Also worthwhile to explore, questions of freedom vs. security.

Does any of this prove helpful to you? It seems to be a very interesting topic, please let us know what sorts of ideas you begin to develop.


VAdm Robert Seldon, (Jacob)
Chief of Fleet Development

FDragonetti
Registered User
(2/7/03 11:37 am)
Reply

Re: Curiosity...
THank you for the reply, Jacob. That will probably help, but I am interested in others' opinions as well. There is no definite length, the only requrement is that it is a philosophical essay.

RAdm. Dragonetti
Commanding Officer
USS Patriot, NCC-26782
Director of Defense

RAGEJL
Registered User
(2/7/03 12:19 pm)
Reply

Re: Curiosity...
Actually Whit we do have a limit of like 1,000 or 1,500 words or something like that...also for Jacob's and anyone else who replies we have the Just War Doctrine outlining what is just war and how it can be waged to use as reference...its mainly relating to is finding evidence connecting a nation's leaders with terrorism a just enough reason to wage war on that nation...personally I think America is quite the hipocrit in this regard did we not fund insurgents in Panama against the Colombian governing in the early 20th century so we could build our precious canal? Did we not fund and train rebels in Cuba (led by no other than Fidel Castro) against the legal standing government under Batista and then once Fidel rose to power embargoed the country? Are we not currently training and supplying Iraqi 'refugees' so they can oust the current regime? Did we not fund Afghani rebels for years and years since the 1980's in their war against the Soviets and the Taliban, when the Taliban was the current legal government...if these arn't acts connecting our government to terrorism I dont know what is...just because we win doesn't make the issue morally right and or condemn us as hipocrits in the rest of the world's eyes...something to chew on...peace

-J. Asuka

RhianChal
Registered User
(2/11/03 4:50 pm)
Reply

Re: Curiosity...
I have written a short discourse on the Internet and privacy in this age of increased security. If you like, I can e-mail it to you. Just make sure to cite it properly, lest I become very angry.

hallet
Registered User
(2/16/03 4:03 pm)
Reply

Interested
That sounds very interesting could you email to me as well.

RhianChal
Registered User
(2/19/03 9:14 pm)
Reply

Re: Interested
I could, but I need your e-mail address.

Lt. (j.g.) Rhian Chal
Warp Core Specialist
USS Minerva, NCC-36181

<< Prev Topic | Next Topic >>

Add Reply

Topic Control Image Topic Commands
Click to receive email notification of replies Click to receive email notification of replies
Click to stop receiving email notification of replies Click to stop receiving email notification of replies
jump to:

- IDFleet Forum - General Conversations - IDFleet Home Page -

Powered By ezboard® Ver. 7.32
Copyright ©1999-2007 ezboard, Inc.