The Crossing
    > Literature
        > Book burning and related rubbish...
New Topic    New Poll    Add Reply

<< Prev Topic | Next Topic >>
Author
Comment
Sanduleak
Wordsmith
Posts: 82
(1/6/02 3:22 pm)
Reply

Book burning and related rubbish...
There's been the usual round of extremist nutters (my personal take ;) ) indulging in ritual book burnings of the "Harry Potter" fantasy books for kids. This is the cutting edge of a phenomenon that has been around for a good long while where some people take what appears to be an innocent bit of fun and turn it into something evil.

Is there too much read into things that appear in the media? Are we running the risk of analysing every little thing into oblivion? Do we run the risk of stealing away the fun and magic from our kids that we enjoyed as kids? Am I being naive?

Your thoughts please...

Pete Earsman
Traveller in the arts
Posts: 8
(1/7/02 7:15 pm)
Reply

Re: Book burning and related rubbish...
This is a very thorny subject.

I subscribe to the school that believes that everyone is responsible for their own feelings.
The kernel of objectionable (writing, movies, whatever) is intent.

If someone deliberately sets out to offend me, mine, or something which I hold dear, then I will offend them right back, in spades.
I neither want nor need any Thought-Police looking after my interests.

We are in real danger of becoming a generation of dishonesty, where we judge actions/writings/attitudes of the past in the forum of the present. Always a dangerous proposition.

Winstone Churchill said, 'If we try to move forwards while looking backwards, we are going to fall over things.' or words to that effect.

There was a case not too long ago where recently uncovered journals of a French exploratory party in late 18th century Australia made derogatory remarks about the indigenous people. There is a movement now to have those remarks expunged from the journals. This is outrageous in my opinion. As misguided, insensitive or just simply profoundly inaccurate as these comments may be, they are still historical comment and as such should be sacrosanct.
Allow people to read them and to comment on them. But to remove them is just plain wrong.

Are we so wimpish that we cannot read, absorb, and judge comment and opinion (with which we disagree) for ourselves?

My two cents worth.


PE


andyarmi
Leeds United Supporter
Posts: 4
(3/10/02 9:26 pm)
Reply

Re: Book burning and related rubbish...
How on earth could Harry Potter inspire anyone to practice Black Magic? It's ridiculous!

In any case, I've tried a number of the spells from the first two books and none of them worked. There's nothing to worry about.

csvsfsadf
Unregistered User
(3/13/03 3:51 am)
Reply

sdl;fkasjd
Hey, I aggree, why would it posess anyone to do that!?

<< Prev Topic | Next Topic >>

Add Reply

Email This To a Friend Email This To a Friend
Topic Control Image Topic Commands
Click to receive email notification of replies Click to receive email notification of replies
Click to stop receiving email notification of replies Click to stop receiving email notification of replies
jump to:

- The Crossing - Literature - The Crossing -

Powered By ezboard® Ver. 7.32
Copyright ©1999-2007 ezboard, Inc.